Have you ever enjoyed watching a professional sports event that has no real meaning? You probably have seen the occasional preseason game by accident while flipping through the television channels and thought nothing of it. You could be a season ticket holder who gets tickets for the preseason games and felt like attending because you had nothing better to do. I am personally not a big fan of preseason since it does not really serve any purpose from a fan’s perspective. Naturally, preseason lets players who normally never play get a chance to shine, like wide receiver Victor Cruz of the New York Giants, or a critical player gets injured and misses the rest of the season, like kicker Shaun Suisham of the Pittsburgh Steelers. However, there is a glorified preseason game that stands out above the rest, one that strides itself on getting the fans to play Fantasy General Manager to field a team. I am referring to the All-Star Game. Fan voting in All-Star Games have always been mired in some kinds of controversy and every time people call the fan vote into serious question.
The National Basketball Association ige, like DeMarcus Cousins of the Sacramento Kings, Andre Drummond of the Detroit Pistons, and Isaiah Thomas of the Boston Celtics, who must rely on the coaches giving them a spot on the bench to show their skills.
The Major League Baseball All-Star Game is the most intriguing of the four for the fact that former commissioner Bud Selig made two critical decisions that altered the way the game is played. The 2002 All-Star Game ended in a 7-7 tie after both teams used up all their available pitchers, a decision that caused controversy for Selig. The next season featured an interesting way to prevent ties from occurring: the winner of the All-Star Game gets home-field advantage for the World Series. That call has made the All-Star Game worth watching, but it comes as a double-edged sword. Remember Derek Jeter’s final season as a New York Yankee? He was elected to be the starting shortstop of the American League and Adam Wainwright of the St. Louis Cardinals admitted in postgame interviews that he threw soft pitches so Jeter could get at least one hit in his final All-Star Game. Jeter helped lead the American League to victory, which gave the Kansas City Royals home-field advantage in the 2014 World Series against the San Francisco Giants. Despite Wainwright’s admitted actions, San Francisco won in seven games. The idea of fans voting in the starters for the All-Star Game is nothing new, and usually baseball fans are not easily swayed by name recognition, but they are not perfect and have been prone to controversy.
Have you ever cared about the 1957 Cincinnati Redlegs? I highly doubt it, but the Cincinnati fans sure did and they wanted to recognize their team in the 1957 All-Star Game held at the old Sportsman’s Park in St. Louis. Now, either the Cincinnati faithful wanted to ruffle the feathers of the hometown Cardinals by voting for players from a divisional rival or they wanted to mess with the system, but when the fan voting was all said and done, seven Cincinnati position players, catcher Ed Bailey, second baseman Johnny Temple, third baseman Don Hoak, shortstop Roy McMillan, and outfielders Frank Robinson, Gus Bell, and Wally Post, were all voted to start the game, the lone non-Cincinnati starter being Cardinals legend Stan Musial. Robinson is the only Cincinnati player that most fans were recognize due to his status as a member of the Hall of Fame, but the rest of the Redlegs are not household names. Baseball commissioner Ford Frick questioned the authenticity of the voting process, so an investigation was launched to determine why the Cincinnati players were voted in. It turns out that the Cincinnati Inquirer made pre-printed ballots and distributed them to fans so they could easily vote in the Redlegs. Frick stripped the fan vote system away and it did not return until 1970. Post was injured at the time of the All-Star Game, so he could not play regardless, but Bell was kept on the team as a reserve while Frick named their replacements in the starting lineup. His choices? Willie Mays of the New York Giants and Hank Aaron of the Milwaukee Braves.
The National Hockey League All-Star Game has been all over the place when it comes to their format. 1947 to 1968 saw the defending Stanley Cup champions play the All-Star Game against players from the rest of the league. 1969 to 1974 eliminated the Champs vs. Everybody Else format in favor of East Division vs. West Division. NHL expansion led to the traditional conference versus conference format as the Wales Conference faced off against the Campbell Conference from 1975 to 1993. The conferences officially adopted the usual Eastern Conference and Western Conference names in 1994 and that style of All-Star Game lasted until 1997. 1998 saw the North America versus the World last until 2002. 2003 to 2010 featured the return of the East vs. West format. 2011 to 2015 featured the Fantasy Draft style of selecting rosters, with two teams led by a captain who selects players. Finally, this year will feature three actual games, with two divisions facing off in a 3-on-3 20 minute game while the other two divisions do the same thing, with the winners facing off in the third and final game. Got all that? Fans do get to vote for players like every other league, but sometimes fans like to mix up the usual star power featured in the game, a prime example being defenseman Rory Fitzpatrick of the Vancouver Canucks, who was voted in to the 2007 All-Star Game despite playing in a mere 18 games and contributing virtually nothing.
The 2016 NHL All-Star Game has four captains for each of the divisions. Jaromir Jagr of the Florida Panthers captains the Atlantic Division, Alexander Ovechkin of the Washington Capitals captains the Metropolitan Division, and Patrick Kane of the Chicago Blackhawks captains the Central Division. All three of those players are staples of the NHL and are deserved All-Star selections. The Pacific Division captain is John Scott of the Arizona Coyotes, which makes sense since the Coyotes are in the Pacific Division, except Scott is not only not on the team, he is not even in the NHL at the moment. Scott was traded to the Montreal Canadiens, who promptly sent him to the St. John’s IceCaps of the American Hockey League. An All-Star Game, especially for a league that has been dogged by lack of national enthusiasm over the years, should be embracing this idea that a journeyman left wing who has scored only five goals his entire NHL career can stand with the very best of the NHL. The fact that the NHL apparently tried guilting Scott into skipping the All-Star Game altogether puts a black eye on what may be the greatest hockey moment of this man’s life. The game may be pointless to some, but fans love to see the guy who does not belong with the rest to be at center stage. Scott is just living out his dream of playing professional hockey and fans wanted to give him a moment he would never forget. The fact that the NHL tried to ruin that moment shows they truly do not understand the meaning behind the event.
The National Football League has the Pro Bowl, but I honestly have never cared about it and neither do the players involved. The selection process of who goes to the Pro Bowl is probably the best format of the four major pro sports leagues, as the selection of players is spilt in three halves. One half is for the fans, one half is for the coaches, and the last half is for the players themselves. While you have the usual name recognition voting, namely the quarterbacks like Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers, players who have come out of nowhere, like running back Devonta Freeman of the Atlanta Falcons, get the recognition and credit that they deserve. Of course with fan voting also comes team favoritism, like in 2008 where a record 13 Dallas Cowboys were chosen to the Pro Bowl. Smaller market teams like the Jacksonville Jaguars and the Tennessee Titans tend to not have national coverage, while teams Dallas and the Pittsburgh Steelers get coverage consistently, so fans know those teams. The player vote is also debatable since players can hold grudges against certain teams, so players on that team suffer as a result.
The only real issue with the Pro Bowl is simple: no one wants to actually play the game. Since the Pro Bowl was moved to the week prior to the Super Bowl, the two Super Bowl participants will not participate due to the significant risk of injury. Star players also tend to avoid the game either due to injury or the fact that the pay for participating is dramatically lower than their salaries. NFL commissioner Roger Goodell has made it known that if the Pro Bowl does not become a better product, then it will be eliminated entirely. Frankly, I think everyone would not mind if that became a reality.
So what have we learned from all this? Fan voting will constantly be called into question due to whether the starters they select are qualified or not. Sometimes it is a legitimate question in cases like Yao Ming’s, while other times it is meant in good fun in cases like John Scott’s. The game itself may be completely pointless and a waste of time for some, but the fans love to see the best athletes in their respective sports perform with no worries at all. If the fans abandoned the sports they love, the leagues will suffer. So, give some love to the John Scotts of the world because they love being recognized like this, whether they show it or not.